A missing person case gets upgraded to murder when the members of an online forum turn to sleuthing.
For 20 years, Shaun believed his uncle Teddy was dead after he left Ireland rather mysteriously and cut ties with his siblings. So when a stranger shows up, claiming that Teddy is alive and was last heard from in New York, Shaun is nonplussed. Still, he’s curious enough to post a picture on the internet looking for information, where it’s picked up by the members of a missing person site who immediately recognize Teddy as “The Boy in the Dress,” found murdered in Minnesota nearly 20 years before, wearing a pink prom dress. The narrative follows Shaun; the website admin, Chris, who has personal reasons to want to solve these cases; website moderator Ellie, who has previously gotten in trouble for getting carried away with her sleuthing; and website enthusiast Pete, who claims to be a former cop and sets up a GoFundMe to bring Shaun to the United States. As the group begins to bond by working the case, someone is manipulating the situation for their own protection; someone doesn’t want the truth about the boy in the dress to come to light—and might be willing to kill to keep their secrets. Lotz’s (The White Road, 2017, etc.) previous novels have hardly been short on either terror or drama; this one is curiously lacking in both. Instead, it follows the slow progress of the investigation, moving appropriately to emphasize the mundanity, perhaps, but devoid in the end of true mystery or suspense. The characters form a likable band of misfits who deserve a more exciting plot. Perhaps there’ll be a second chance in a sequel?
A legitimate but hardly original moral: Be careful whom you trust on the internet.