THE REAL STORY

A whodunit where the “who” and the “dunit” are the least interesting parts of the story.

Cat has just walked in to discover a cookie jar shattered on the floor, the cookies nowhere to be seen. When asked to explain what happened, cheeky Mouse is more than happy to oblige. Mouse tells a story of how the cookies, tired of being cooped up, destroyed their own jar and are now wandering the countryside, free. “Honestly we should be happy for them.” When Cat doesn’t buy it, Mouse follows up the tale with one about a slimy monster, then one about an alien named Georgette, then one about a bug with multiple hungry relatives. Cat screams for Mouse to just tell the real story, so Mouse does. “I stole and ate all the cookies, and then the jar fell and broke. The end.” Morality isn’t in question here. In fact, it’s only at this point that Cat realizes how dull the truth can be. Ultimately, Cat asks for another cookie story, which Mouse provides…for a cookie. Brimming with marvelous read-aloud potential (frustrated characters make for fantastic vocal oscillations), Ruzzier’s latest provides plenty of laugh-out-loud moments, many stemming from Cat and Mouse’s odd-couple relationship. The text is simple enough for younger readers, while the surreal watercolors are the perfect complement to Mouse’s out-of-this-world imaginings.

A superb celebration of storytelling when the truth proves insufficient.