TROUBLE ISLAND

A young woman with a difficult past stands up to the Mafia, her best friend, and a host of bad memories when trouble comes to Trouble Island.

It’s 1931. For reasons we don’t know, Aurelia Escalante has been exiled to a remote island surrounded by the icy waters of Lake Erie, an island owned by the McGee crime family. She and Rosita, the estranged wife of crime boss Eddie McGee, used to be friends, but a string of murder and tragedy has put strain on their relationship—as well as the fact that Aurelia is treated like domestic help on the island. When Eddie and a small entourage arrive one frigid November day, intending to convince Rosita to sell the island to a rival family, Aurelia has just put in motion a plan to escape, aided by the lockbox full of gold and jewels she’d found washed up on the shore. But there will be no easy opportunity to slip away. Instead, Aurelia finds herself embroiled in what is essentially a game of Clue: As people on the island start dying, she must uncover past truths and false identities while doing her best to preserve her own secrets. The plot is full of more twists and turns than a Chutes and Ladders board, and Short throws in some flashbacks for good measure. Though we don’t fully understand what drives Aurelia, first to align herself with the McGees and then to have the strength and chutzpah to break that bond, until the very end of the novel, her cunning sense of self-preservation—plus a little help from a handsome bodyguard and a kindly domestic couple—keeps her alive, and keeps the pages turning. The isolated setting is well-rendered, and while not all the murders are necessarily weighty, nor all the solutions logical, the book has enough style and flash to make it worth reading.

A spunky heroine plus a beautiful, unusual setting make this a must-read.