PERFECT ON PAPER

A teenage relationship expert deals with some tricky situations.

Every student at St. Deodetus’ school in California knows about locker 89: Slide $10 and a note confessing your relationship woes inside, and you’ll get an email with personally tailored advice. The anonymous proprietor, junior Darcy Phillips, enjoys crafting letters and has a high customer satisfaction rate. She’s always been careful to collect the letters after school, when no one’s around, and has managed to escape detection until Australian rich kid Alexander Brougham catches her in the act. Instead of spilling her secret, he hires her as a private coach to help him rekindle things with his ex-girlfriend. Darcy agrees—as a faculty kid on scholarship, the extra cash is welcome—but finds that dealing with a customer face to face has unique challenges, particularly given Brougham’s curt demeanor and reluctance to share basic information. Meanwhile, Darcy’s own love life (crushing on her best friend, Brooke Nguyen) continues to stump her expertise. This story is a classic teenage rom-com packed with misunderstandings and slow-burn attraction. The culmination of the main storylines is more than satisfying. In contrast to the unsuccessful parental relationships on display, Darcy gives well-researched advice that prioritizes communication, consent, and healthy realism. Gonzales similarly presents mature perspectives on recreational drug use and biphobia. There is strong representation of various queer identities, with some racial diversity implied through names; Darcy is bisexual and presumed White.

Thoughtful and well executed.