THE PUZZLE BARK TREE

In Gertler’s conventional second (Jimmy’s Girl, 2001), an unhappily married woman inherits a lake cabin that unlocks secrets from the past and opens her to true love.

Grace and her younger sister Melanie were raised almost entirely by a housekeeper who lavished affection upon them—fortunately, since their parents were distant and withdrawn. Now married to an unloving cardiologist in Manhattan and the mother of a perfect teenaged daughter, Grace is shocked when her aged parents commit joint suicide and even more shocked to learn she has inherited a house on an island in upstate New York she never knew existed. Since her husband, selfishly, has gone off to Aspen for a vacation with their daughter, Grace travels alone to Diamond Lake in the dead of winter. Almost immediately she meets Luke, a local guide, and is strongly drawn to him. Soon after, sister Melanie comes to keep Grace company, and Luke takes them across the frozen lake to the island house where he reveals the shocking secret most readers will already have guessed: Grace had an older brother who drowned in the lake when he was nine and Grace three. Her previously lively, warm parents were devastated and never recovered. Further, Grace’s brother had been Luke’s best friend, and Luke has mourned his loss for 40 years. Little wonder he and Grace feel a mutual attraction. But Grace must return to her family—and before she can resolve her feelings for Luke, her husband has the gall to suffer a heart attack. She feels obligated to nurse him back to health, but his illness only points up the emptiness of the marriage. While their daughter is in Europe for the summer, Grace heads back to Luke and Diamond Lake, her husband to his boob-jobbed girlfriend in Aspen. Soon everyone is living happily ever after.

Dull romance. The most interesting character is the husband no one (except his daughter) likes.