TRUE CRIME REDUX

The crime that inspired a crime writer comes back to haunt her.

One morning in 1973, Kane’s soon-to-be mother-in-law, Betty, was murdered. While Betty’s husband, Duane, was investigated for the murder, he eventually walked free, leaving Kane—and the rest of Betty’s family—to reckon with the aftermath. For the author, that meant writing a crime novel loosely based on the violent events, though by the time Quiet Time was published, she and Betty’s son had gotten divorced. As a result of that book’s publication, the cold case was reopened, and Kane eventually had to testify. In this uneven narrative, she revisits the circumstances of the original crime, including witness statements, court papers, police reports, and her own conversations with family members. Kane’s stated intent is to examine how her own fictionalized account unwittingly played a role in these events. The short, stunted chapters certainly add to a quick-paced, suspenseful flow, but Kane’s writing is often so fractured and truncated that significant analysis eludes her. She repeats information without elaborating on it, and she fails to examine the motivations, mindsets, and even basic reactions of her characters, none of whom are satisfyingly rendered—not even her ex-husband, Doug. In fact, she doesn’t describe Doug’s reaction to his mother’s murder until halfway through the book. Even then, the description is sparse. Almost 10 years after the murder, Doug spoke to a sister about the tragedy. “This was the first time he’d said he wanted to talk to one of his siblings about his mother’s death,” writes Kane. “He took the bus to Philly. When he returned, he was shattered. She couldn’t believe I had doubts, he told me. She always knew Dad killed Mom.” While the author excels at pulling together a mountain of documents, her analyses—and many of her descriptions—leave much to be desired.

A suspenseful read that asks more questions than the author is prepared to answer.