Kirkus Reviews QR Code
A DIFFERENT KIND OF FAIRY by Susana Torrubiano

A DIFFERENT KIND OF FAIRY

From the Égalité series

by Susana Torrubiano ; illustrated by Giulia Orecchia

Pub Date: June 18th, 2024
ISBN: 9788419607904
Publisher: NubeOcho

A fairy stops granting wishes that don’t align with her traditional values.

Light-skinned and pink-clad Rose has been granting wishes as “the pink fairy” for thousands of years—almost as long as she’s been alive. But when children start asking Rose for things that don’t conform to gender norms, Rose is perplexed. She won’t let “a pretty little girl” be a rugby player or “a handsome little boy” be a dancer. Instead, she just flies off with a “Goodness me!” leaving the children confused and upset. Their wishes go unfulfilled. Despite intervention from her fairy friends, Rose refuses to grant wishes, and her behavior becomes even odder as she begins to menacingly chase the kids. The children start to fear the pink fairy instead of looking forward to her visits. Surprising herself, Rose realizes that her true passion is scaring children and that she wants to be an ogre instead. She begs the fairy queen to make it so. This unique fairy tale—translated from Spanish—sparkles with its message that "hurt people hurt people." Some may be perturbed, however, that Rose is ultimately rewarded for her harmful actions rather than held accountable (though many of the kids seem to enjoy the scares). Nonetheless, Orecchia’s colorful, textured art creates a magical and inviting world. The children and fairy friends alike are racially diverse. Some have multicolored outfits, too—a nice visual representation of open-mindedness against Rose’s monochrome look.

Magical and message-driven but slightly off the mark.

(Picture book. 4-8)