Kirkus Reviews QR Code
WALKER EVANS by Svetlana Alpers

WALKER EVANS

Starting From Scratch

by Svetlana Alpers

Pub Date: Oct. 20th, 2020
ISBN: 978-0-691-19587-2
Publisher: Princeton Univ.

A fresh, scholarly look—complete with more than 200 images—at the seminal American photographer, this time through the lens of fine art and literature.

In a lavishly illustrated narrative bolstered by impassioned research, art historian Alpers reintroduces readers to Walker Evans (1903-1975), one of America’s great artistic observers. Evans began his career dreaming of becoming an expat writer like those of the Lost Generation, and Alpers finds a literary core at the center of his creative makeup. In addition to “having an eye” for photography, Evans was a storyteller and a ruthless editor of his own work. He was meticulous about word choice in his writing and public speaking; in his photography, he tirelessly revised, endlessly searching for the perfect crop. Evans was an avid reader, and Alpers turns to books to unlock his oeuvre (Flaubert looms large). She similarly mines the realm of art history but occasionally reaches too far: After astutely likening the documentarian nature of her subject’s undeveloped rolls to a painter’s plein-air sketchbook, she goes on to compare Evans to Paul Cézanne and his many graphite studies. Elsewhere, she connects Evans to Edward Hopper, but “coming as I do from historic European art, the horizontal, two-page composition reminds me of a fifteenth-century Italian predella panel.” Alpers periodically touches on Evans’ well-documented commercial projects—e.g., Let Us Now Praise Famous Men, his celebrated collaboration with James Agee—but primarily searches for new ways to understand Evans’ work as a whole. She resists seeing his work as nostalgic; quoting Evans, she explains that he was “interested in what any present time will look like as the past.” Recalling critic Clement Greenberg, Evans saw photography as “the most literary of the graphic arts,” and Alpers convincingly presents him as a new kind of poet: “a photographer inventing a new language of images for America.”

Great American photography in a welcome new frame.