WHITE RURAL RAGE

A view of rural America as a font of white privilege—and of resentment that the privileges aren’t greater.

Political scientist Schaller and journalist Waldman open with an example taken straight from the headlines: the uproar over Jason Aldean’s song “Try That in a Small Town,” with its implied promises of retribution in a “fantasy of vigilante violence meted out against urbanites supposedly ready to bring their criminal mayhem to the idyll of rural America.” While it’s true that rural America has been suffering, rural Americans haven’t exactly helped themselves. “There is no demographic group in America as loyal to one political party as rural Whites are to the GOP that gets less out of the deal,” write the authors, showing how this situation arose because no rural political organization exists to make the vast region an object of true interest for either Republicans or Democrats. Schaller and Waldman come close to blaming the victim in that analysis, but, as they painstakingly document, rural white Americans actually enjoy outsize influence in such things as electoral votes, to say nothing of the increasing rightward radicalization of the GOP. It’s no coincidence, they note, that nearly 75% of the votes opposing the certification of Joe Biden for president came from rural congressional districts. There’s a certain vicious circularity at work: With few news sources reaching out to rural audiences, radio is king, and radio is almost invariably hard right in orientation, eager to fuel the resentment that comes from the sense that the “real America” is disappearing in the face of demographic change. So it is that while white rural America is getting poorer, sicker, and more isolated, it’s also getting angrier—and that anger is poisoning the rest of the nation.

A book of broad explanatory power that’s not likely to help mend any fences.