COUNT TO THREE

A Sacramento shamus and her ambitious assistant search for a teenager whose abduction was witnessed by their preteen client.

Most private eyes wouldn’t touch a case at the behest of Ethan Grant. The kid smokes in front of them, has limited financial resources, and is only 12 years old. But both members of the Callahan Agency have their reasons for agreeing to look for Ali Cross, a high school–age painter whom Ethan saw knocked out and bundled into a van as he watched from a distance, paralyzed by fear. Quinn Sullivan hopes to make a case for her full partnership in the agency. And Dani Callahan still can’t forget the day five years ago when her daughter, Tinsley, left her first day of kindergarten with a woman dressed exactly like Dani and vanished. The trauma drove Dani and her husband, Matthew, apart, and now that he’s married Carole, a woman who won’t need the expensive fertility treatments that produced Tinsley, he just wants Dani to get over her loss. But Dani can’t get over it, and her inability to do so urges her to look for Ali, identify the mysterious figure who keeps breaking into attorney Cameron Bennington’s house, figure out why Quinn’s mother never came home from grocery shopping years ago, and identify the woman who kidnapped Tinsley. Readers hooked by Ragan’s earlier suspensers, such as No Going Back (2021), will wait with bated breath to watch all these threads come together—unless perhaps they don’t and have to be laboriously untangled one strand at a time.

By-the-book thrills lead to a cascade of anticlimaxes.