Kirkus Reviews QR Code
MR. BEAR'S BIRTHDAY by Virginie Aracil

MR. BEAR'S BIRTHDAY

From the Mr. Bear series

by Virginie Aracil ; illustrated by Virginie Aracil ; translated by Wendeline A. Hardenberg

Pub Date: Aug. 4th, 2020
ISBN: 978-1-03631-825-2
Publisher: Twirl/Chronicle

Mr. Bear’s birthday guests are on their way!

There’s a party at Mr. Bear’s house, and a madcap group is invited: animals (among them an “always cold” pup in knit cap and puffy coat), humans (one is a pale goth girl accessorized with a snake), and even a visitor “from far away” (an aggressively green, party-hat–clad ET). The eclectic guests include a sloth zooming in a wheelchair, one child with a single parent and another with two dads, and a gender-nonconforming child with a stereotypical boy’s haircut who “likes to wear dresses.” All the aforementioned humans present White; there is only one guest of color, a Black child with an exuberant Afro who, in a rather offensive touch, bears a comb as a gift. “Everyone is invited” is an earnest message, but it gets lost among the long, meandering list of attendees, with the promised party an afterthought. Set against brilliant backgrounds, the dapper guests are illustrated in a portrait style, with their prominent heads gazing out at readers. Labeled, disappointingly flimsy fold-out flaps concealing the gifts accentuate the fantastical ambience, with a “portable radio” present from a rhino in his undies and a first-edition Proust from a bibliophile bear. An almost comically oversized trim has scale problems: It’s cumbersome for lap children, but the foldouts are too small to use in group settings.

Good intentions notwithstanding, this French import is not really a reason to celebrate.

(Board book. 2-5)