WE'LL NEVER TELL

Four teens get involved with a 1970s Hollywood murder mystery.

Casey, Jacob, Eddie, and Zoe are the anonymous creators behind We’ll Never Tell, a popular YouTube channel which features them sneaking into exciting off-limit sites around Los Angeles. As their senior year comes to an end, they decide to go out with a bang by trespassing and entering the so-called “Valentini murder mansion,” the site of an infamous, presumed 1972 murder-suicide involving two Hollywood darlings. After they get inside, however, they realize the house is not as untouched as it should have been. The night ends with Jacob getting stabbed and bleeding out in one of the rooms while the other three scramble to get out before they’re caught by the police. In the days that follow, Casey—whose own backstory is full of trauma—becomes suspicious that one of her friends may be the culprit and that the truth may be connected to what happened in the past. This fast-paced thriller follows Casey in her attempt to uncover the truth. The narrative also includes some chapters from Jacob’s viewpoint leading to the night of the break-in. While sophisticated readers may figure out the mystery before it is revealed, the historical elements are intriguing, and the characters’ relationships, especially the romance between Jacob and Eddie, are highlights. The book follows a White default; Zoe’s mother is from the Philippines, and Eddie is cued Chinese American. Casey is also queer.

An enjoyable, character-driven whodunit.