ELEPHANTS ARE NOT ARTISTS

In this debut picture book, an elephant refuses to let the opinions of others discourage her passion for creating art.

Inspired by Ruby, the real-life Phoenix Zoo elephant who painted abstract artworks after being supplied with materials, Hart reframes the story with a message for children: Believe in yourself. This tale’s Ruby knows what she wants to do—create art—and she won’t be limited by the expectations of others. Snooty passersby (a hawk, a snake, and a gazelle) tell her: “Elephants are not artists.” Ruby remains unfazed. And although the message would have had added resonance if the author had allowed Ruby to overcome a moment of self-doubt, she represents a model of unshakeable self-confidence and resistance to peer pressure. The text—a clear black font for the narrative, with lighter, idiosyncratic fonts identifying each speaker in the story—is set against artist Law’s cartoon-style, digital illustrations in serviceable outdoor settings (greens, browns, and blues predominate). While the diverse humans are awkwardly rendered, the gazelle adds an unexpected dash of visual drama, and Ruby is endearingly expressive. Ruby’s only wish: to create her designs in color and “share the beauty she sees with everyone.” Thanks to a kindly human zookeeper, Ruby is given the wherewithal to do just that. The author earnestly underscores the little elephant’s happiness by urging kids to think about and pursue, “like Ruby,” what they “love to do.”

An animal tale with pleasant visuals and heartfelt encouragement for children to follow their dreams.